Friday, July 11, 2025

Glyn Davis’ parting advice recommends a visit to MOAD

Glyn Davis reflects on the routines, values and quiet architecture that give policymaking its legitimacy — if ethics stay in the frame.

Former Prime Minister & Cabinet (PM&C) secretary Glyn Davis has championed the ‘Spirit of the service’ exhibition for those wanting to better understand the foundational policy principles upon which the Australian government operates. 

A few weeks after closing the door to his office for the last time, Davis spoke of how the work of governing is messy and continuous. He also acknowledged that the academic theory of the policy cycle can seem overly optimistic when it butts against the brutal cut and thrust of politics.

The policy cycle is illustrated on an exhibition wall at the Museum of Australian Democracy (MOAD), as part of a relatively new installation about the APS in 2023.


Davis said the conceptualisation — featuring elements including well-designed processes, the collation of evidence, room for contrary assessments and testing for unintended consequences — was a good example of the “enduring” settings of the policy world that superseded generations of politicians and governments of the day.

“A policy cycle can seem an optimistic model when the truth may be muddle, happenstance or brute politics,” Davis told an audience in Canberra.

“But with no idea of what good policy making might look like — no Platonic ideal — how can you assess experience or strive toward a better process?”

Every week in his job at PM&C, Davis said, he noticed the policy cycle embedded in routines of governing– so ubiquitous they were often taken for granted — bringing to life the institutional architecture of governing.  

From inviting decision-makers and policy drafters to answer key questions — such as the template for cabinet submissions that asked what is the problem being addressed, why these policy instruments and not others, what do other agencies across government think of the proposal, what implementation schedule is proposed, how will the new initiative be evaluated? — to the sharing of information across portfolios that delivered a shared context for priorities to be determined and choices to be made.

These ways of working had become so natural, Davis added, that public servants often forgot how profoundly they shaped the work of the APS, but created routines that provided a path for authority to flow and legitimacy of actions to be accepted. 

“At any one time, very few established programs — and little of the overall budget — is up for scrutiny and debate. This stability allows a policy cycle time to work. 

“Policymaking can follow a cycle of problem identification, deliberation, adjustment and evaluation,” Davis said. 

“When ministers and their officials meet in committee, they work from a common body of information, using well-established processes to guide the discussion.

“Routines are the standard operating procedures of government. They provide the unseen and unreported daily work of public servants — something we forget at times to include in our account of how government operates,” he said. 

The nature of deciding economic policies and questions about national security all involved a combination of a sustained conversation across time between ministers, advisers, the public service and stakeholders.

Davis further suggested that protocols and processes for policymaking required decisions made in haste to be “defended and sustained”, and also allowed for bad policy decisions to disappear “when the moment passes”.

“That does not imply policy is unchanging. The world shifts, generations turn over, and the consensus about government moves slowly but remorselessly,” Davis said.

“Even climate change has gone from deeply contested to widespread acknowledgement and grudging agreement on action.”

The senior mandarin said routines and protocol together helped to infuse a level of reliability and flexibility in government systems, but they also needed to be tempered by values like stewardship and commitment to service to ensure processes did not steamroll other important features of effective government.

Things like innovation, ways to avoid “bad bureaucratic behaviour” or systems that excluded people from decision-making processes. 

“When the rules clash with our ethical underpinnings, as happened in robodebt, something is terribly wrong and needs urgent attention,” Davis said. 

“Effective administration … depends on public servants committed to their vocation. A capable public service needs good leaders, and seasoned administrators deeply knowledgeable about government, willing to work well together, able to provide ministers with thoughtful advice — whether wanted or not.

“A well-functioning system needs integrity,” he said.

Professor Davis said he had long been intrigued about how public policy was made, and shared a sliding door moment during his early career that would have led him to either join the public service or lecture about public administration as “an outsider looking in”. 

It turns out you can do both, the former secretary quipped, revealing that on completion of his tertiary studies, he accepted a position lecturing at Griffith University over an offer to commence in a graduate role with the Department of Communications.

This saw Davis go on to teach a future treasurer, Jim Chalmers, an assistant minister, and other students who would become serious public service powerbrokers at the state and federal level.

“I worked with talented colleagues to develop undergraduate courses on policy making, and wrote the first local textbook in the field,” Davis said.

“It was a delight to teach committed students who shared our interest in the subject.”

As a lecturer, he recalled one of his former students scoffing that academics couldn’t possibly know the real-world challenges of balancing good policy and making tough choices.

Some years later, in an airport, Davis bumped into his former pupil. This student had risen to the highest echelons of power and served as a minister in the Howard government. 

“‘You know that stuff you and the others taught us about cabinet and ministerial responsibility and how policies get made?’… [He] then answered his own question, with genuine astonishment: ‘It all turned out to be true!’,” Davis said. 

“The feedback was gratifying, yet his original critique haunts. Can we really teach the reality of something as ever-changing, yet intricate as government?”

As someone who lived through the scandalous final years of Queensland’s Bjelke-Petersen regime (1968-87), Davis said that he understood government corruption and lip service paid to the rule of law risked undermining trust in everything worth caring about in public life.

Lost integrity could be hard to win back, he warned.

“Ours is an urgent, restless world. So much injustice still, at home and abroad, so many questions,” Davis said. 

“Leading PM&C was a chance to observe the seriousness with which ministers take their responsibilities and the professionalism of an APS in serving whatever government is chosen by the Australian people.

“A public service which … has been striving for effective local delivery, more joined up services, better procurement and greater opportunity for community empowerment since the Coombs royal commission nearly 50 years ago. It is a journey that continues,” he said.

Professor Davis made his remarks in a valedictory speech marking the end of his tenure as the top mandarin of the APS. The event was hosted by IPPA ACT. 

About the author

Melissa Coade

Melissa Coade

News editor
Melissa Coade is The Mandarin’s news editor based in Canberra’s parliamentary press gallery. She has had various government, communications and legal roles, and has written for the Law Society of NSW journal (LSJ) and Lawyers Weekly.

 Glyn Davis’ parting advice recommends a visit to MOAD

Turns Out Appeasing Trump Only Emboldened Him


New ‘ATO’ tax scam tricks 2FA, puts myGov users at risk A new ‘
ATO’ phishing scam is targeting Australians at tax time, bypassing 2FA to steal myGov credentials and other personal information
When Leongatha father Simon Patterson put on his tax return in 2022 that he was separated, it set off a lethal chain of events.
The relationship between him and his estranged wife, Erin Patterson, deteriorated well before a mushroom lunch killed three church parishioners as the pair quarrelled over child support payments and where their children would go to school.




The quiet courage of frank and fearless leadership

The public service ideal of being ‘frank and fearless’ meets its toughest test in today’s political climate. History, literature and leadership collide in this quiet reckoning.


Bloomberg, IRS to Lose 22% of Taxpayer Service Workers After Trump Purge:

The IRS should quickly hire thousands of new taxpayer service employees so it’s prepared for next year’s filing season, given the agency is losing more than one-fifth of those workers under Trump administration-directed oncuts, the National Taxpayer Advocate said in her mid-year report.

The Trump administration should lift its hiring freeze and the agency needs direct-hire authority to fill key roles by the end of the summer ahead of the 2026 season, Erin Collins, the national taxpayer advocate who runs an independent office inside the IRS, said. The IRS’s Taxpayer Services division, which helps consumers with questions on their taxes and processes returns, is expected to lose about 22% of its 42,134 workers.



2024 Erwin N. Griswold Lecture Before the American College of Tax Counsel: Globalization and its Fallout: Ten Years of International Tax Tumult




Musk calls Bannon a ‘fat, drunken slob’ and says he should be arrested as their feud rages on The Independent


Elon Musk’s proposed new political party could focus on a few pivotal congressional seats The Guardian


Elon Musk floats strategy for new political partyAxios


Air Force Halts Project With Musk’s SpaceX Daily 


Turns Out Appeasing Trump Only Emboldened Him

The American Prospect: “…Biden appointed a milquetoast moderate, Merrick Garland, as attorney general, and as The New York Timesand Washington Post reported in detail, he initially refused to prosecute Trump on his globally televised sedition and insurrection, instead attempting a traditional organized crime roll-up that went nowhere and ate up months. 

It wasn’t until the January 6th Committee made Garland look like an idiot that he finally got moving in November 2022—eighteen months after Biden took office—and it was special counsel Jack Smith who actually put the cases together, relatively quickly. 


These years of delay allowed Trump’s cronies on the Supreme Court to successfully delay the resulting trials out past the 2024 election. When Trump repeatedly refused to return classified documents he had stolen from the National Archives, the FBI raided Mar-a-Lago only with extreme reluctance, and did not arrest him. When the Colorado Supreme Court threw him off the 2024 ballot in that state, the national Supreme Court quickly put him back on. 


In short, the American law enforcement apparatus, egged on by many prominent liberal and lefty academics and commentators, bent over backwards to provide the appearance of due process—which is to say that Trump got to get away with outrageous things no other defendant would have, like refusing FBI requests during a legal search, or repeatedly violating a judge’s order not to attack the judge’s daughter on social media. (Needless to say, this is the opposite of due process: It is letting a powerful person violate the rules.)

We now see the results of granting Trump his second, third, and 50th legal chances: He is attempting to turn the United States into a fascist dictatorship. Immigrants and other enemies of the regime are being kidnapped off the street by ICE goons with no due process, and stuffed into concentration camps Trump is opening around the country, like the  Alligator Auschwitz in Florida, or sent to slave labor camps in foreign countries. Already, people are starting to die in the cramped and unsanitary conditions. Senate Republicans just passed a bill that, among other things, would balloon the ICE and deportation budget up to $175 billion—giving it more money than the Marines or indeed any military save that of China and the U.S., and giving Trump his own gestapo. Now Trump is openly threatening to strip people of their citizenship and deport them, including Zohran Mamdani, the democratic socialist who recently won New York’s Democratic mayoral primary.  As usual under fascism, Trump is also engaged in monumental corruption. He just collected a straight-up $16 millionbribe from Paramount, which settled a preposterous lawsuit against 60 Minutes because it wants merger approval from Trump. As the Times recently reported, Trump’s finances (which were quite shaky in late 2024) have since improved greatly thanks to various cryptocurrency schemes—an Abu Dhabi investment firm said it would use Trump’s stablecoin to buy Binance for $2 billion—and hawking crummy products to his devoted followers.

Thursday, July 10, 2025

Justice Dept. Explores Using Criminal Charges Against Election Officials

NY Times Op-Ed: A Surprising Route To The Best Life Possible


Justice Dept. Explores Using Criminal Charges Against Election Officials

The New York Times: “Senior Justice Department officials are exploring whether they can bring criminal charges against state or local election officials if the Trump administration determines they have not sufficiently safeguarded their computer systems, according to people familiar with the discussions.

Stem cells from extracted wisdom teeth are like “medical gold,” able to treat multiple diseasesEarth.com


Exclusive: Trump Orders Military to “Deter” ChinaKen Klippenstein


Chris Marsden: New head of Britain’s MI6 is granddaughter of Ukrainian Nazi mass murdererOlivier Boyd-Barrett

A Pro-Russia Disinformation Campaign Is Using Free AI Tools to Fuel a ‘Content Explosion’

"It's not the size of the dog in the fight, it's the size of the fight in the dog"

- Mark Twain


ATO tech spend review backlash over lack of detail


NSW ombud, ICAC demand end to reported misconduct gag orders

Silencing staff with legalese? NSW integrity bodies say not on their watch. Deeds of release don’t trump the public interest — or the law.


 'Fly in, fly out criminals' preying on elderly in $3 million 'blessing scams' saga


Dive into the research topics where Geoffrey Hawker is active. These topic labels come from the works of this person. Together they form a unique fingerprint.


Managers And Clowns 3 Quarks 

Paramount’s Trump settlement hands CBS News a black eye

The company caved to a meritless lawsuit to smooth its merger path and undermined its own journalists in the process


Your browser lets websites track you even without cookies

ZME Science – Most users don’t even know this type of surveillance exists: “On the internet, it’s easy to feel anonymous. If you don’t log in, no one can see who you are; you can even switch to incognito mode. The more savvy user would say that’s not really enough. To be anonymous, you need to clear your cookies and use a privacy-oriented browser



Wired no paywall: “Consumer-grade AI tools have supercharged Russian-aligned disinformation as pictures, videos, QR codes, and fake websites have proliferated. 

A pro-Russia disinformation campaign is leveraging consumer artificial intelligence tools to fuel a “content explosion” focused on exacerbating existing tensions around global elections, Ukraine, and immigration, among other controversial issues, according to new research published last week

The campaign, known by many names including Operation Overload and Matryoshka (other researchers have also tied it to Storm-1679), has been operating since 2023 and has been aligned with the Russian government by multiple groups, including Microsoft and the Institute for Strategic Dialogue

Wednesday, July 09, 2025

China's Spy Agencies Investing Heavily in AI

 

A Pro-Russia Disinformation Campaign Is Using Free AI Tools to Fuel a ‘Content Explosion’

Wired no paywall: “Consumer-grade AI tools have supercharged Russian-aligned disinformation as pictures, videos, QR codes, and fake websites have proliferated. A pro-Russia disinformation campaign is leveraging consumer artificial intelligence tools to fuel a “content explosion” focused on exacerbating existing tensions around global elections, Ukraine, and immigration, among other controversial issues, according to new research published last week

The campaign, known by many names including Operation Overload and Matryoshka (other researchers have also tied it to Storm-1679), has been operating since 2023 and has been aligned with the Russian government by multiple groups, including Microsoft and the Institute for Strategic Dialogue

The campaign disseminates false narratives by impersonating media outlets with the apparent aim of sowing division in democratic countries. While the campaign targets audiences around the world, including in the US, its main target has been Ukraine. Hundreds of AI-manipulated videos from the campaign have tried to fuel pro-Russian narratives. 

The report outlines how, between September 2024 and May 2025, the amount of content being produced by those running the campaign has increased dramatically and is receiving millions of views around the world…”


 How nuclear war could start
The Washington Post Opinion
 Climate and Humanitarian Consequences of an even Limited Nuclear Exchange and the Actual Risks of Nuclear War
Webinar
 Starlink hazard
WashPost
 DOGE layoffs may have compromised the accuracy of government data
CNN
 Slashing CISA Is a Gift to Our Adversaries
The Bulwark
 Most Americans Believe Misinformation Is a Problem— Federal Research Cuts Will Only Make the Problem Worse
PGN
 As disinformation and hate thrive online, YouTube quietly changed how it moderates content
CBC
 ChatGPT goes down—and fake jobs grind to a halt worldwide
Pivot to AI
 They Asked ChatGPT Questions. The Answers Sent Them Spiraling.
The NY Times
 News Sites Are Getting Crushed by Google's New AI Tools
WSJ
 Can AI safeguard us against AI? One of its Canadian pioneers thinks so
CBC
 Bad brainwaves: A ChatGPT makes you stupid
Pivot to AI
 They Asked an AI Chatbot Questions. The Answers Sent Them Spiraling
NYTimes
 SSA stops reporting call-wait times and other metrics
WashPost
 Pope Leo Takes On AI as a Potential Threat to Humanity
WSJ
 AI Ethics Experts Set to Gather to Shape the Future of Responsible AI
ACM Media Center
 Hacker Group Exposes Source Code for Iran's Cryptocurrency
Amichai Stein
 Iran Asks Citizens to Delete WhatsApp from Devices
AP
 China Unleashes Hackers Against Russia
Megha Rajagopalan
 China's Spy Agencies Investing Heavily in AI
Julian E. Barnes
 Amazon Says It Will Reduce Its Workforce as AI Replaces Human Employees
CNN
 ChatGPT will avoid being shut down in some life-threatenign scenarios, former OpenAI researcher claims
Techcrunch
 Big Tech two-factor authentication compromised
Bloomberg
 What could go wrong? - AllTrails launches AI route-making tool, worrying search-and-rescue members
National Observer
 EU weighs sperm donor cap to curb risk of accidental incest
Steve Bacher
 ChatGPT may be eroding critical thinking skills
MIT
 Meta's Privacy Screwup Reveals How People Really See AI Chatbots
NYMag
 Tesla blows past stopped school bus and hits kid-sized dummies in Full Self-Driving tests
Enadget
 Couple steals back their own car after tracking an AirTag in it
AppleInsider
 Finger Grease Mitigation for Tesla PIN Pad
Steven J. Greewood
 San Francisco bicyclist sues over crash involving 2 Waymo cars
Silicon Valley
 I lost Spectrum for about two hours
LA Times via Jim Geissman
 How scammers are using AI to steal college financial aid
LA Times
 U.S. air traffic control still runs on Windows 95 and floppy disks
Ars Technica
 States sue to block the sale of genetic data collected by DNA testing company 23andMe
LA Times
 Using Malicious Image Patches in Social Media to Hijack AI Agents
Steven J. Greenwald
 Weather precision loss
Jim Geissman
 Grief scams on Facebook
Rob Slade
 Info on RISKS (comp.risks)